Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

When results are available, navigate with up and down arrow keys or explore by touch or swipe gestures.

Top-rated vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Guest favorite
Cabin in Custer
★Nature Stay with Views Like No Where Else★
This home is magazine worthy and one of a kind! Modernly furnished to an excellent standard. It is the ideal retreat for a secluded & nature-bound stay. You can open the windows and let the sounds of the creek make you feel like you are in paradise. It is Conveniently located near Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park, and other major tourist destinations. It's less than 5 minutes to Hill City! We believe it is the ultimate location to immerse yourself in the beauty of the Black Hills.
Jan 23 – 30
$179 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Hill City
Cabin - 20 acres w/ horses, goats & mini donkey
Spend the holidays in the Black Hills! Two bedrooms w/ queen size beds and loft w/ queen size pullout sofa allow you to comfortably sleep 6! Just 4 miles from downtown Hill City. Sits on 20 beautiful acres surrounded on 3 sides by Forest Service! Enjoy beautiful surroundings - a seasonal pond outside your cabin (water level varies), horses, and a mini donkey and mini goats. Enjoy private setting with the convenience of the owners just 1/4 mile up the driveway to take care of your needs!
Jul 8 – 15
$450 per night
Guest favorite
Guesthouse in Rapid City
Stoneridge Ranch
Looking for something off the beaten path to enjoy some peace/quiet? We’re just that, tucked away in the beautiful Black Hills only 30min from Rapid City & several favorite attractions: Mt Rushmore, Reptile Gardens, Bear Country, Needles Highway, Rushmore Caves + many more. Our property has opportunity to see lots of wildlife(deer, turkeys) and including our animals: a horse, a pony, 2 goats, 2 dogs & 2 cats. Runners take advantage of the gravel/paved roads for a scenic/peaceful run.
Aug 12 – 19
$100 per night

Popular amenities for Horse Thief Lake vacation rentals

Other great vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guest favorite
Cabin in Black Hills
Seldom Inn Guest House
Jul 22 – 29
$235 per night
Guest favorite
Cabin in Custer
Tenderfoot Creek Retreat
Oct 23 – 30
$175 per night
Superhost
Cabin in Rapid City
Amazing Creek-side Vacation
Apr 23 – 30
$275 per night
Guest favorite
Loft in Custer
Downtown Loft
Nov 10 – 17
$80 per night
Guest favorite
Guest suite in Custer
The View at Bear Rock (Full Guest Suite)
Aug 6 – 13
$136 per night
Guest favorite
Cabin in Keystone
The Winsome Cabin - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins
Nov 22 – 29
$171 per night
Guest favorite
Cabin in Keystone
GlassLodge, SD Bucketlist to Stay
Aug 12 – 19
$505 per night
Guest favorite
Cabin in Hermosa
Elkview Lodge
Sep 29 – Oct 6
$135 per night
Guest favorite
Apartment in Keystone
Blue Pine Suite by Mt. Rushmore
Apr 10 – 17
$161 per night
Superhost
Home in Keystone
Chalet Mt Rushmore VIEWS Hot Tub
Dec 17 – 24
$241 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Custer
New modern home near Sylvan Lake.
Apr 17 – 24
$425 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Keystone
Luxury Living in the Black Hills!
Jun 22 – 29
$386 per night

Destinations to explore