Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Lime Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Lime Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Home in Machias
Lake House w/ dock, fish + swim!
Relax at this beautiful 2 bed, 1 bath lake house! Includes 2 large outdoor decks, lake access, and a dock, to swim and fish! Boat rentals, restaurants, diners, coffee shops, and bars. *The dock and lake access are a short walk from our home* (about 150 yards) Home is 14 miles away from some of the best ski resorts upstate NY has to offer - including Holiday Valley Ski Area. Fully stocked kitchen, walk in closets, high speed wifi, smart TVs in every room, a BBQ, fire pit, and a washer/dryer.
$111 per night
Home in Machias
Little Log Cabin on the Lake!
Relax, vacation and make memories on picturesque Lime Lake in Machias NY. This sunny, cozy home is perfect for people who'd like some solitude while watching the spectacular sunsets on the lake! This fully furnished, waterfront cottage includes a glassed-in sunroom to enjoy your morning coffee as the sun rises. Enjoy boating, swimming and fishing. Boat dock, rowboat, gas grill and firepit included for your enjoyment. A 20-minute drive to Ellicottville where you can enjoy shopping and dinner.
$175 per night
Cottage in Delevan
Hillside Cottage on Lime Lake, NY-scenic setting!
2 BR, 1.5 Bath Cottage on Lime Lake in a beautiful setting with all new updates. Sleeps 6- with a queen sized bed, twin over full bunk and queen size sleeper sofa. Just a few doors down from the Lime Lake Snack Shack and a 20-minute drive to Ellicottville, NY. Whether you enjoy the bursting colors of the fall leaves, skiing/snow activities, ice fishing, renting a pontoon for a day on the lake or summer fun activities, or just a relaxing getaway- this is a place for all seasons!
$157 per night

Other great vacation rentals in Lime Lake

Home in Delevan
Modern, 2BR Lakefront Cottage
$165 per night
Rental unit in Machias
Lime Lake 3 bedroom getaway
$73 per night
Cottage in Delevan
Cozy ski and summer cottage on Lime Lake
$161 per night
Guest suite in Springville
Cozy Cabin Suite with a View
$108 per night
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Cattaraugus County
  5. Lime Lake