Skip to content

Vacation rentals in New Wilmington

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Wilmington

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Cabin in Salem
The “Dreamcatcher” Treehouse with Private Hot Tub
The "Dreamcatcher" Treehouse is a unique secluded hideaway perched high above the scenic ravine and rolling creek. In an enchanted wooded setting, a winding gravel pathway leads to the whimsical rope suspension bridge entering the treehouse. Stunning views await from floor to ceiling windows, and the spacious cantilevered deck with oversized hot tub and glass fire pit. With upscale modern design featuring beautiful cozy interiors and comfort at every turn, your stay will be a welcome retreat.
$198 per night
Home in Sharpsville
The Bicycle House
Recently remodeled and tastefully furnished, this two-bedroom house boasts a unique charm, with many antiques and comforts to make you feel at home. Conveniently located within a few miles of Interstate 80 and the border of Ohio and Pennsylvania, this house is only an hour drive from both Pittsburgh and Cleveland. Whether you are coming home to visit friends and family, want to get away for the weekend, or are traveling for business or pleasure, the Bicycle House is a memorable place to stay.
$120 per night
Guest suite in New Wilmington
Safe Haven - Modern Getaway in Amish Country
Come relax in our private 2 bedroom , full bath retreat. Your area has its own private entrance so you can come and go as you please. It includes a kitchen and living room for your comfort. Located 0.8 mi. from Westminster College in the middle of Amish country. Start your day with complimentary Keurig and fresh local made Apple Castle donuts. You can also enjoy tax free shopping at the Grove City Outlets minutes away.
$134 per night

Stay near New Wilmington's top sights

The Tavern on the Square6 locals recommend
Westminster College7 locals recommend
Gilliland's Market4 locals recommend

Other great vacation rentals in New Wilmington

Home in Grove City
Charming Cape Cod Home Walking Distance to GCC
$124 per night
Chalet in New Castle
Rainbow Bend
$150 per night
Guest suite in Grove City
Sunny Grove City Loft Apartment Near College #3
$70 per night
Home in Hermitage
The Shay Shack •1.2 Acre Farm House In Town•
$89 per night
Townhouse in Grove City
Perfect Townhouse Close to College and Downtown
$124 per night
Loft in Ellwood City
Charming Studio
$63 per night
Home in Slippery Rock
Spacious 3 bedroom home with plenty of green space
$125 per night
Home in New Castle
Amish Paradise
$240 per night
Guest suite in Grove City
Suite Hideaway - secluded one bedroom apartment
$87 per night
Apartment in Portersville
The country house
$160 per night
Apartment in New Wilmington
Lovely 1 bedroom Carriage House
$175 per night
Cottage in Mercer
Charming Farm Cottage
$99 per night

Destinations to explore