Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Fairy Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Fairy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Apartment in Burlington
Town of Burlington Apartment
If you like quite country living then this is the place for you to stay! You have the apartment all to yourself with no sharing of resources. The apartment is thoroughly cleaned and disinfected between all guests. Distance from: Burlington - 4 miles - 8 min Country Thunder in Twin Lakes - 10 miles - 16 min Lake Geneva - 10 miles -15 min Alpine Valley - 16 miles - 20 min Milwaukee - 38 miles - 50 min Chicago -80 miles - 1hr 30 min
$80 per night
Apartment in Elkhorn
FarmWise Country Stay by Alpine Valley/Lake Geneva
Retreat to a quiet countryside experience at this all organic farm, where you can sit back, relax, and enjoy the country charm of your private space inside the main farm house. Optional for you are joining us for early morning chores in the barn. If you tell me the night before, you can try milking Carmel, the cow by hand, feeding the pig, collecting eggs from the chicken coop and more. Most loved of all are our friendly cats!
$95 per night
Chalet in Williams Bay
The Bay Chalet
Featured in "At The Lake" Magazine in 2022! Enjoy the Northwoods of Lake Geneva! Just a 2-minute drive to the Williams Bay public beach on Geneva Lake, lakefront park, boat launch and restaurants. 10 minutes to downtown Lake Geneva. Soak up the woods, a giant deck, a million stars, fire pit and the cabin atmosphere while so close to all the Lake Geneva area has to offer.
$216 per night

Other great vacation rentals in Fairy Island

Home in Lake Geneva
Beautiful Home w/ Hot Tub in Lake Como, Wisconsin
$64 per night
Condo in Lake Geneva
Charming, Cozy & Quaint Condo in Lake Geneva!
$103 per night
Cabin in Hubertus
Hugel Hutte - Log Cabin Getaway
$193 per night
Cabin in Lake Geneva
Cozy Winter Escape - Lake Geneva
$231 per night
Cabin in Williams Bay
Rustic Cabin with Small Town Feel
$155 per night
Bungalow in Lake Geneva
Private Cozy Cottage Lake Geneva, WI
$175 per night
Home in Wales
Beautifully Restored Historic Victorian
$103 per night
Home in Lake Geneva
The Lake House
$170 per night
Apartment in Lake Geneva
Geneva Street Inn in Maple Park Historic District
$139 per night
Home in East Troy
Lakeside Getaway
$195 per night
Guest suite in East Troy
Mini Moon Hideaway
$83 per night
Farm stay in East Troy
Unforgettable, romantic getaway + old world charm
$140 per night

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Wisconsin
  4. Walworth County
  5. Troy
  6. Fairy Island