Skip to content

Buckeye Lake house rentals

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Buckeye Lake

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Home in Buckeye Lake
Relaxing 2 bedroom cottage near lake w/ hot tub
Welcome to Lakehaven Cottage! Relax and have fun at this peaceful 100 year old cottage close to the lake with modern amenities such as a flat-screen smart Roku tv, 300 Mbps WiFi, a fully equipped kitchen and comfy beds with lots of pillows and blankets. Within walking distance to the beach, marina/boat launch, 4.1-mile lakeside path, bars, and restaurants. Play air hockey/ping pong or relax in the fully fenced in yard with hot tub, fire pit or gazebo for grilling, dining and relaxing.
$152 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Buckeye Lake
The Lake House for Family & Friends
Enjoy a stylish new lake house across the street from the north shore of Buckeye Lake. Public boat ramp less than 1/2 mile. Walk to the boardwalk, restaurants, Yacht Club, ice cream, Boat Yard for bike or kayak rental or just enjoy a drink with live music. Fenced yard for small pets (no more that 25 lbs accepted) or enjoy enclosed front entry way to watch the sunset. Roku TV & wi-fi available. Two bdrm, bath, laundry on main floor. Master bdrm upstairs gives a view of the lake.
$148 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Thornville
Main Lake Cottage on Buckeye Lake
Welcome to Duck Inn Too! Duck Inn Too is completely renovated with all new appliances and is a perfect place to relax and enjoy all seasons. There is no better way to relax than sitting on the deck and enjoying the amazing views of the lake. Even though Buckeye Lake is known for summer fun, the off-season vibe and relaxing and quiet atmosphere make Duck Inn Too a great place to recharge! Summer dates are currently available and we are accepting bookings!
$257 per night
SUPERHOST

Stay near Buckeye Lake's top sights

Photo of Buckeye Lake Winery
Buckeye Lake Winery41 locals recommend
Photo of Pizza Cottage
Pizza Cottage18 locals recommend
Photo of Our Lakeside Diner
Our Lakeside Diner9 locals recommend
Photo of Dragon Village of Buckeye Lake
Dragon Village of Buckeye Lake6 locals recommend
Photo of Buckeye Lake Brewery
Buckeye Lake Brewery27 locals recommend
Photo of Donatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza3 locals recommend

Lake side house rentals in Buckeye Lake

Home in Buckeye Lake
New Home - "See More" at the lake
$200 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Thornville
Stunning 3BR Waterfront home on Buckeye Lake
$743 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Thornville
Waterfront home with pool
$721 per night
Home in Buckeye Lake
Beautiful Lake House in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.
$643 per night
Home in Buckeye Lake
Buckeye Lake Getaway - 4 bdrm, 2.5 bath, Game Room
$346 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Millersport
Your home away from home on Buckeye Lake!
$371 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Lancaster
Lancaster LuxuryColumbus Close Private Apartment
$99 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Millersport
Lake escape at Buckeye Lake
$700 per night
Home in Thornville
Oasis by Buckeye Lake
$299 per night
Home in Hebron
Home away from home - fenced yard a block to lake
$241 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Buckeye Lake
Lubber's Lane-Remodeled Buckeye Lake Home
$363 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Thornville
Beautiful Lake Front Home on Private Canal!
$457 per night

Buckeye Lake vacation rentals

Cottage in Thornville
Little House on main lake of Buckeye Lake
$206 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Buckeye Lake
Newly renovated 2-bedroom cottage by the lake
$103 per night
SUPERHOST
Cabin in Buckeye Lake
Little Red Cabin @ Buckeye Lake
$140 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Millersport
The Chelsea Cottage: Cozy Buckeye Lake Lakeview
$162 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Buckeye Lake
Cheerful 3 bedroom cottage near lake with hot tub
$204 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Buckeye Lake
Cozy Lake Cottage Just Steps Away From The Lake
$185 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Buckeye Lake
3BR 2 Bath w Dock option
$159 per night
SUPERHOST
Vacation home in Buckeye Lake
Cheerful 3-bed vacay home w/free car &boat parking
$141 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Buckeye Lake
Anchors Away - Relaxing Cottage Minutes from Lake
$221 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Buckeye Lake
Memory Lane, A Charming Buckeye Lake Cottage!
$171 per night
SUPERHOST
Townhouse in Thornville
King Bed Luxury Home next to Buckeye Winery & Lake
$165 per night
SUPERHOST
Cottage in Millersport
Gorgeous Lakefront Cottage on Sellers Pt 3BR-2Bath
$300 per night

Buckeye Lake fishing house rentals

Home in Howard
Family Fun Luxury Lakehouse for up to 10 People
$510 per night
Home in Howard
Peaceful Lakefront Getaway w/ Gameroom
$163 per night
Home in Rockbridge
The Chestnut - Hocking Hills lakeside retreat!
$246 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Rockbridge
1800s Hocking Hills Restored Farmhouse
$260 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Millersport
Perfect Buckeye Lake Getaway! Premium Location!
$799 per night
Private room in Bremen
Secluded Country Estate Get-A-Way; Ground Level
$105 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Howard
Lake Home Inn
$309 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in South Columbus
Cheerful 4 bedroom lake view, patio and kitchen.
$308 per night
Home in Hillsboro
Lakehouse Retreat & DOCK in Rocky Fork State Park
$218 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Howard
Blessed Lake House
$230 per night
Home in Buckeye Lake
Adorable Buckeye Lake Cottage
$180 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Howard
Sandy Shore Lake House Luxurious Lakefront Apple V
$514 per night
SUPERHOST

Your guide to Buckeye Lake

All About Buckeye Lake

Just east of Columbus you’ll find the village of Buckeye Lake, where summer cottages surround the shore of the tranquil lake that shares its name. Family-owned businesses line the town’s quiet streets, and near the town’s center you may come across microbreweries and the Buckeye Lake Historical Society Museum, whose collection of memorabilia invites visitors to take a journey through the area’s past.

Buckeye Lake itself was constructed in 1826 to serve as a feeder canal for the famous Erie Canal. Among the countless islands that dot the narrow reservoir are the Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve, a floating island created when the surrounding swamp was flooded in the 19th century. Buckeye is a popular place for boating and fishing for perch, catfish, and largemouth bass. Around the lake, you’ll also find a few smaller villages, a winery, and Buckeye Lake State Park, Ohio’s oldest state park.


When is the best time to stay in a vacation rental in Buckeye Lake?

Summer is unsurprisingly the busiest time of year, especially on weekends due to the lake’s proximity to Columbus, so it is a good idea to secure your Buckeye Lake rental with that in mind. The weather is hot and sunny then, making it a great time to be out on the water. With fall, the leaves surrounding the lake begin to change, creating a kaleidoscope of colors, and although it is starting to get chilly, you may be able to still get out on the water until mid-October. During the Annual Buckeye Lake Singer-Songwriter’s Festival takes place in early October, many concerts are held on the lakeshores.

By the end of November, you may begin to see the first flakes of snow as the temperature continues to drop, and some local businesses close for the winter. Although January through late March can be extremely cold, you may have a chance to see the lake covered with ice, as well as ice fishermen trying to catch saugeye and crappie.


What are the top things to do in Buckeye Lake?

The Dawes Arboretum

With nearly 2,000 acres of themed gardens as well as wilder natural areas, this tranquil arboretum is an attractive place for nature-spotting and picnicking. Twelve miles of gently sloped hiking trails wend their way through the park, and as you meander along the crisscrossing pathways, you can visit the Japanese garden, azalea garden, and one of the country’s northernmost cypress swamps.

Buckeye Lake State Park

The Buckeye Lake State Park, which encompasses the 3,100-acre Buckeye Lake and 400 acres of surrounding shorelines, is perhaps the main draw for visitors. You’ll find three swimming areas and picnic spots around the park, as well as the paved, four-mile Buckeye Lake Dam Trail. This trail takes you from the village along the shoreline to the Leibs Island Trailhead, passing by cottages and boat docks as you take in sweeping views of the lake and its islands.

Great Circle Museum

Built by a people now known as the Hopewell culture between 100 B.C. and 500 A.D., the Great Circle Earthworks has been a sacred site for Native Americans for more than two millennia. A site for ceremonies honoring the dead or social gatherings, the Earthworks are the world’s largest set of geometric earthen enclosures. The four-square-mile complex also once served as a cathedral, cemetery, and astronomical observatory. This fascinating outdoor museum is located just 20 minutes from Buckeye Lake.

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Ohio
  4. Licking County
  5. Buckeye Lake