Skip to content

Cottage vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

When results are available, navigate with up and down arrow keys or explore by touch or swipe gestures.

Top-rated cottage rentals in Cayuga Lake

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Guest favorite
Cottage in Interlaken
🍷CLOUD WINE COTTAGE FLX🍷secluded w/HOT TUB!!!
Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located place. Located on the Cayuga Wine Trail, with the Seneca Wine Trail 8 miles away. Travel down a long gravel driveway to a modern cottage hidden back in the trees. Enjoy peaceful campfires, relax in the hot tub, watch Netflix or Disney plus on our smart tv, or bring your favorite blue rays/dvds with you to watch. The cottage has a beautiful open floor plan with a fully equipped kitchen for all your cooking needs and fully stocked coffee bar.
Feb 16 – 23
$197 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Canandaigua
Bristol Retreat Cottage, Creekside with Hot Tub
Rest and unwind at this unique, romantic getaway nestled in the beautiful Bristol Hills. Just minutes away from Bristol Ski Resort, Canandaigua and Honeoye Lake, this cozy 1 bedroom 1 bathroom cottage is one of our two homes available along the peacefully flowing Mill Creek. Take in the natural beauty from the large patio and hot tub. Indoors you'll enjoy the gas fireplace, complimentary wifi and smartTV. The full kitchen and bathroom are stocked with many amenities to help you enjoy your stay.
May 15 – 22
$166 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Aurora
Heron Cottage on Cayuga Lake
Heron Cottage is a newly renovated, year-round lakeside getaway on Cayuga Lake! Just 2 miles south of Aurora, and a 5 minute walk to Long Point State Park with access to a public boat launch, swimming/playground/picnic area and stunning lake views. This cozy cottage offers a truly unique experience with beautiful lakeviews and 22 acres of private wooded trails behind it. Heron Cottage is the perfect spot to enjoy Fingerlakes wineries & breweries and is minutes from The Inns of Aurora.
Nov 23 – 30
$249 per night

Popular amenities for Cayuga Lake cottage rentals

Lakefront cottage rentals

Guest favorite
Cottage in Skaneateles
Awesome Sunsets! - Skaneateles Lake!!
May 30 – Jun 6
$259 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Geneva
Emery Rise on Seneca Lake- Waterfront Escape
Jan 17 – 24
$347 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in King Ferry
The Megan House-Cayuga Lake East Shore - Level Lot
May 16 – 23
$192 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
Seneca Lake A-Frame w/Stunning Views, Beach & Dock
Oct 11 – 18
$399 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
Seneca Lake refuge in the middle of wine country
Oct 1 – 8
$264 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Naples
Hook, Wine and Sinker
May 26 – Jun 2
$350 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
Heart of the Fingerlakes Wine Country
Nov 24 – Dec 1
$365 per night
Superhost
Cottage in Seneca Falls
Lakefront Finger Lakes with WIFI Seneca Falls, NY.
Nov 5 – 12
$347 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Dundee
Charming Waterfront Finger Lake Cottage with Dock
Aug 13 – 20
$298 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Lodi
Lodi Lakefront
May 1 – 8
$418 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
Sit Back, Relax, Enjoy ~ No Cleaning Fee!
Jun 14 – 21
$300 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
"Charming Barbara" Cottage on Seneca Lake!
Jun 27 – Jul 4
$164 per night

Cottage rentals with a hot tub

Guest favorite
Cottage in Geneva
Seneca Sunsets: private lakefront, dock, hot tub
Jan 8 – 15
$384 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Aurora
Sunset Haven Cottage
Dec 13 – 20
$199 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Lyons
Peppermint Cottage
May 5 – 12
$210 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Branchport
Comfort and Luxury- Keuka Lake Dream Property
Dec 22 – 29
$313 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Canandaigua
Lake Escape >HOT TUB< *Steps to the lake* >Skiing<
Oct 10 – 17
$231 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Dundee
Moonlight Bay On Seneca Lake with a hot tub.
Nov 6 – 13
$377 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Ithaca
Beautiful Cayuga Lakehouse weekly rentals July Aug
Mar 10 – 17
$349 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Dundee
Lakefront Cottage on Seneca
Dec 7 – 14
$248 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Branchport
Keuka Lakefront House on West Side with Hot Tub
Nov 26 – Dec 3
$225 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Naples
Canandaigua lake - Heron Cove Sanctuary
Dec 23 – 30
$179 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Trumansburg
Beach/Hot Tub/Parking/Wi-fi/Kitchen/Laundry Room
Oct 17 – 24
$600 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
The Willow Haus: Seneca Lake Wine Trail w/ Hot Tub
Sep 9 – 16
$280 per night

Pet-friendly cottage rentals

Guest favorite
Cottage in Lodi
Winery Cabin - Relax on the Ridge
Nov 5 – 12
$176 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Lansing
The Cottage: Cozy one bedroom in Lansing NY
Aug 30 – Sep 6
$137 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Penn Yan
On Lake, Stunning Views, Sunrises, Pet Friendly!
Jan 8 – 15
$411 per night
Superhost
Cottage in Skaneateles
Skaneateles Lake Cottage - Private Retreat!
Nov 26 – Dec 3
$299 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Ithaca
Upper Bunk - ADA accessible suite at New Park Even
Nov 22 – 29
$225 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Canandaigua
Private & Spacious w/ Lake Access! Full Kitchen
Apr 15 – 22
$258 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Corning
Cozy Cottage
Oct 31 – Nov 7
$120 per night
Superhost
Cottage in Himrod
Back-Achers Cottage 2
Jul 12 – 19
$160 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Rexville
Crows Nest Cabin Eco-Forest-Farm
Dec 15 – 22
$142 per night
Superhost
Cottage in Romulus
3 BR Wisteria Cottage on Seneca Lake
Jul 29 – Aug 5
$650 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Canandaigua
Cottage with Canandaigua Lake Acces
Dec 6 – 13
$113 per night
Guest favorite
Cottage in Rochester
Quiet 2 bedroom cottage with mid-century decor
Mar 14 – 21
$103 per night

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Cayuga Lake
  5. Cottage rentals