Skip to content

House vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

When results are available, navigate with up and down arrow keys or explore by touch or swipe gestures.

Top-rated house rentals in Cayuga Lake

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
2 BR/2B Lake house Minutes from Town and Campus!
Beautiful lake views, amazing location, cozy, modern, comfortable, & peaceful. These are a few of the most common remarks from our guests. The perfect lake living on the water while still minutes from town! Treat yourself to coffee/tea every day while watching the sunrise over the lake from dual balconies/the dock. This is a two-story home w/ 2 bedrooms & 2 full baths. Accessible to Ithaca's finest restaurants, Cornell University & Ithaca College, wineries & all the Finger Lakes have to offer.
Jun 29 – Jul 6
$946 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
Magical lakefront treehouse, minutes to downtown
A magical treehouse perched over its own gorge on Cayuga Lake. This place is special! There’s a giant porch wrapped around a 300-year oak tree and a lakeside tea house that can serve as an extra bedroom. There’s a dock, fire pit, room for yard games by the water, plenty of outdoor seating on the porch, by the lake, or on the dock. All of this is minutes from downtown Ithaca, Cornell, and Taughannock Falls state park. It’s also a great base to explore the Finger Lakes wine region.
Oct 7 – 14
$542 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Union Springs
Lake Home on Cayuga- No Airbnb Fees!
*The host has covered 100% of the guest Airbnb fees on this 90 ft of private lake front property* Have dinner on the screened in porch while watching the sunset. Roast marshmallows by the fire pit. Jump off the dock and swim in fresh water or float alongside on the kayaks provided. Take a wine tour by boat. Hike trails and see the waterfalls at our local state parks. Rent a boat from the marina next door. For couples, families, friends, and water enthusiasts, this has it all!
Jan 4 – 11
$214 per night

Popular amenities for Cayuga Lake house rentals

House rentals with a pool

Guest favorite
Home in LaFayette
The Honeycrisp House at Beak & Skiff
Apr 27 – May 4
$489 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Newfield
Camp S’mores- An A-Frame for the modern traveler
Sep 18 – 25
$949 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Fairport
Esten-Wahl Farm - Historic Landmark Victorian Home
Oct 23 – 30
$428 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
Haven Woods, quiet house, minutes to Ithaca w/ AC
Apr 22 – 29
$280 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Phelps
Four Season Country Home Finger Lakes, N.Y.
Nov 28 – Dec 5
$275 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Lima
Theater room, fireplace, & pool
Feb 2 – 9
$309 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Sayre
Beemans home on the hill.
Jun 21 – 28
$274 per night
Superhost
Home in Penfield
Penfield-Webster Home w/Pool - Park Like Setting
Jul 22 – 29
$270 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Trumansburg
Private Cottage with Pool Between the Lakes
Apr 19 – 26
$185 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Seneca Falls
Goose House
Nov 29 – Dec 6
$889 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Skaneateles
Stunning Lake Views + boutique decor
Mar 14 – 21
$274 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Hammondsport
Modern Lakeside Villa with Pool and Hot Tub
Aug 11 – 18
$810 per night

Weekly house rentals

Guest favorite
Home in Seneca Falls
Pristine Lakefront House On Wine Trail
Feb 20 – 27
$500 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Romulus
Magnolia Lakeside Cottage
Mar 20 – 27
$249 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Geneva
Drift Away: Hot tub, kayaks, fireplace & PAC-MAN
Oct 22 – 29
$437 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Seneca Falls
Quiet Accommodations Seneca Falls
Apr 17 – 24
$72 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
Modern home w/ Hot Tub & big yard 2 miles to Falls
Feb 8 – 15
$329 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Skaneateles
Gorgeous Lake Home Spectacular View
Nov 16 – 23
$373 per night
Superhost
Home in Ithaca
Pet Friendly Lakefront Kayak Canoe Firepit Sleep 6
Dec 17 – 24
$521 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Newark Valley
Private Scenic Retreat
Feb 14 – 21
$87 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Penn Yan
Charming Keuka Lake Waterfront Cottage...
Feb 17 – 24
$179 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
Hayt's Chapel
Jun 27 – Jul 4
$126 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Keuka Park
Mutual Fun Keuka Memories
Nov 14 – 21
$176 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Penn Yan
The Carlin Cottage on Keuka Lake
Sep 9 – 16
$261 per night

Private house rentals

Superhost
Home in Moravia
Corry’s Cove Hosted by Corry & Allison Murray
Oct 11 – 18
$303 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Burdett
Infrared Sauna & Hot Tub for 2-EV charger
Jan 8 – 15
$266 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Trumansburg
Historic Village Retreat: 2 BR home near Main St.
Apr 19 – 26
$157 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Geneva
Right Next Door
Dec 12 – 19
$89 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
Awesome House on Cayuga Lake! (age 35+ excl. kids)
Dec 21 – 28
$214 per night
Superhost
Home in Interlaken
Serene Lakeside Retreat w/ Private Dock & Viewdeck
Sep 6 – 13
$471 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Ithaca
Beautiful Lake Front Living!
Oct 11 – 18
$274 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Cayuga
Cozy & Cheerful 3 bedroom house w/indoor fireplace
Aug 8 – 15
$200 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Romulus
Balcony View Guest House (priced from 4-8 people)
Mar 25 – Apr 1
$493 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Geneva
Sunsets on Seneca Lake
Mar 20 – 27
$280 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Romulus
Log Home Leisure
Sep 3 – 10
$314 per night
Guest favorite
Home in Seneca Falls
Cayuga Lake Front Home
Oct 17 – 24
$825 per night

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Cayuga Lake
  5. House rentals